Posted by: Richard | June 5, 2007

RememberTheMilk.com - a quick review

RememberTheMilk.com is becoming quite a popular to-do list manager. And they’ve got partners everywhere. You can now use RememberTheMilk from your Google Calendar, IM Program, and with your cellphone via SMS. You can get widgets, gadgets, and modules for it. It really is the kitchen sink of to-do lists.

The interface is very sleek. You can create a list, add tags, locate the tasks, add due-dates, and everything. It’s very appealing.

Because it is such a dandy product, I would really like to use their to-do lists. In fact, I was thinking about partnering with them. There’s only one problem though - I just can’t use it.

Now, I’m sure there are lots of other people who like it, but I don’t quite think it suits me. Despite their incredible skills in interface design and marketing I don’t think they understand what being organized is all about. (I think it suffers from the same problem as ta-da list in that respect.) It’s simply a list management tool. It isn’t ever really going to be better than a paper list. It’s still quicker to write things and find them again on a piece of paper than it is to use my cell-phone or laptop to look up anything. (Another score for diyplanner.com. :) ) And to be frank, it just doesn’t fit with GTD, which still seems to be by far the best time-management process I’ve ever seen.

Another thing I learnt from RememberTheMilk is that it is very easy to confuse a user. I tried to enter a task with a due date. But when you click the “add task” button, you only get the option to enter the description of the task. You have to save it, then add a due date later. I found that really confusing. Plus there was no calendar widget to find a date with. I wanted to add a task for this weekend, but as I had no idea what date it was this coming Saturday, I tried to enter “weekend” in the due-date field (as I had been prompted to do). Unfortunately “weekend” was a word which the super-dee-duper recognition system couldn’t recognize, and I got an error message. It’s amazing how quickly I gave up.

I thought it would be nice to use an API to communicate with it, but it doesn’t have that feature yet neither. Guess they’re busy integrating with other partners instead.

So lessons learned: 1. Creating widgets helps you get eyeballs, because that indirectly forms partnerships with other companies. 2. An application should do something which a quicker system can’t do as well.

Responses

RTM has a great API, you can google it. My wish is that you could pass actual and completed task details into WP to make a full project communication system.

Your description doesn’t sound like the app I have been using for 2 years now.

Dates and timezones are the hardest thing to do on the internet and I haven’t found one that does it better. Maybe you are tring to levitate before you can crawl - try dates in numbers first ;-) In you example you could have entered “Saturday”.

I use RTM with brasilian colleagues who were using it fully within an hour - sharing tasks, tagging, prioritising. They type in portuguese, I do english and the dates, timezones and everything works.

If you want a simple interface you could just use the front end for mobiles m.rememberthemilk.com - Works like diyplanner

Tchao

Dave

Hey Dave,

You’re right. I just checked out the API. I couldn’t find it before. It looks quite comprehensive. It looks like a lot of thought went into it actually.

It’s interesting to find out you’ve been using it so long. What is it that has kept you tied to it? The simplicity? How would it compare to tada-list (from 37signals), for example?

I’m not quite sure I’m with you on passing in completed task details. Why would you want to do that?

Richard

We ran a comparison with all the apps at the time and RTM did collaboration, rss feeds, sms and worked with all the browsers. Tags, multilanguage and smart seaarches have embedded it with my colleagues and for domestic stuff.

We use a blog for project change management and posting completed RTM tasks would help everyone visualise issues in one place. I am currently working out an RTM widget to get around this. Best

Dave

And from now on I think I will use it with Twitter. Very nice. Works better than on Flurry.

Leave a response

Your response:

Categories